“Chronic Failure of Provinces, is making Pakistan a Failed State.”



  • “Chronic Failure of Provinces, is making Pakistan a Failed State.”

    Failure of Provinces in Subjects of Education, Health and Police (Law and Order).

    Provinces are very proactive in demanding provincial autonomy but their performance in Provincial subjects of Education, Health and Police (Law and Order) is zero and infact X , Inspite of Donations of Billions of Rupees from Federal Government and International Organizations provinces has chronically failed in delivering any thing to common people, the details of failure of provinces are as follows:

    Performance of Provinces in the subject of Education:

    *In Examinations cheating is common.

    • Even bribe is demanded from position holder’s students from the official of Boards.

    *Standard of education has been totally destroyed in government’s schools.

    *Even poor people do not like to admit their children in government schools

    *Schools have been converted into Otaaqs and leisure rooms of addicted people.

    *Literacy rate is stagnant from last 25 years.

    • Teachers are recruited on political and ethnic basis without any merit.

    *Ghost schools are common without any teaching, fake teachers are gaining salaries.

    • Practice of molesting innocent children by teachers in government school is

    Common.

    • Citizens and children are denied their right of education on the basis of ethnicity.

    • On the basis of ethnicity admissions are given in colleges without any merit.

    Performance of Provinces in the subject of Law and Order (Police):

    *Provinces are using subject of Police as Jobs Banks for their ethnic and provincial supporters instead of recruiting people on merit for maintaining law and order.

    *When any person is recruited in police a huge amount of money is taken from that man as bribe.

    *When any one retires from police department he is required to pay money as bribe for the processing of his pension documents.

    • Even no proper training is given to policemen for maintaining law and order by provincial governments.

    • Even no proper training is given to policemen for their own safety by provincial governments.

    *Policemen are performing their duties without wearing any protective helmets and bullet proof jackets.

    *Due to provincialism, ethnocentrism and racialism prevailing in structures of provinces, policemen are not committed with their duties and do not have any motivation for prevention of crimes and evils.

    *Due to provincialism, ethnocentrism and racialism, Policemen are involved just in making money by taking bribes from common and noble people.

    *Policemen are frightening noble citizens for taking bribes from them, but are friends of criminals involved in narcotics trade, social and morals crimes.

    *Due to no commitment with any moral and ethical Ideology and due to disease of provincialism and ethnocentrism, criminals are committing their crimes freely and police Department is totally inefficient in protecting the life and property of people which is obvious from following examples.

    1. Merciless killing and massacre in Karachi on 12 May 2008, in which police and provincial government were found helping the criminals, and officially no investigation was made by provincial government against such delirious crimes.

    2. Loot and arson on 27 December 2008, on the day of death of Benazir Bhutto, free hand was given to criminals for each and every type of crime by provincial governments and police and Railway and transport of people of other provinces was main target of these criminals, and later on all cases these against these criminals were removed by Chief Minister of Sind.

    3. 0n 27 December once again police of province failed event to protect the property of people and free hand was given to criminals in committing their crimes.

    Moreover whenever people ask provincial police to help them as their duty and responsibility police never help to people.

    In case of snatching a car and Motor cycle when people go for registration of FIR to police, even then police ask for payment of bribe when the person is himself suffering from great trauma.

    From above examples it is quite clear that disease of ethnocentrism and provincialism has become a cancer for common people and has become a main source of victimization of noble citizens and this disease is destroying all moral values and all state institutions.

    Performance of Provinces in the subject of Health:

    *Hospitals maintained by Provincials Government (such as civil Hospital Karachi) have been converted into ruins.

    • Admissions in Medical Colleges are given on the basis of Ethnic basis.

    • Provincial government had established Medical colleges in different cities on ethnic basis.

    *Medical colleges have become places of promotion of provincialism and ethnocentrism.

    *Medical Treatment is given to patients in hospitals on the basis of their link with any ethnic or political party and not on the basis of humanity.

    *Due to lack of motivation and any ethical commitment all program of polio and Tuberculosis eradications have failed.

    *There is no visible program for eradication of HIV, AIDS and Hepatitis.

    *There is continuous flow of population from India into Pakistan having Diseases like AIDS, HIV, Hepatitis, Swine Flue and Tuberculosis but provincial governments are doing nothing to block or to monitor to people coming from India into Pakistan.

    *Pakistan is leading country in the world whose population is suffering from Diabetes, Heart Diseases and Tuberculosis but provincial governments visibly are doing nothing for controlling such diseases.

    • Even children are selling drugs on medical stores without any license.

    • Provincial Drugs Inspectors are involved in corruption and malpractices.

    • Citizens are unable to gain any drugs from hospitals even vaccines are not provided to infants and children for eradication of Diseases.

    • Even in city of Karachi there is not only shortage of water but also water is usually without any treatment and having sewerage contamination.

    • There is no monitoring of food items sold in hotels, resturants and on road side.

    • There is no program by Provincial government for prevention of diseases.

    Now with the blessing of eighteen amendments made by our blind, dumb and deaf parliamentarians, these foolish parliamentarians have handed over all the health and education affairs to provinces without any monitoring system, which is resulting in the destruction of education and health affairs of the country, at present there is no inspection and monitoring is going on in provinces of health and educational institutions and every one is busy in filling his pockets.It is strange that even UN has programms and departments related with health and education, such as WHO and Unicef but federal Government and parliament of Pakistan has relieved it self from all responsibilities with reference to health and education.

    From above examples it is quite clear that disease of ethnocentrism and provincialism has become a cancer for common people and has become a main source of victimization of noble citizens and this disease is destroying all moral values and all state institutions.

    Therefore, there should be strict monitoring by Federal Government and international community of Provincial Education, Health and Police (Law and Order) Departments and in case of no improvements then these Subjects should be taken back from provinces to federal Government.



  • No , If provinces are not able to do so than sub provinces should be made and this should be handled on Local bases .



  • No amount of sub-provinces will acheive anything if the people running these provinces are incompetent and dishonest.

    People deserve eveything they are getting. The are the one who voted various parties in power and they should reap the reward for not casting their votes wisely.



  • We urgently need more provinces to solve/tackle problems outlined by M.AKRAM.

    In my view, there should be a province for a population of 10 million which means we need 18 provinces.



  • anyname

    '

    People deserve eveything they are getting. The are the one who voted various parties in power and they should reap the reward for not casting their votes wisely.

    '

    People voted for zia who ruled 11 years or people voted for mush who ruled 9 years ????

    We need to give control of resources to provinces and maximum autonomy to provinces.



  • Yes, by all means give control of resources to provinces BUT what makes you think that those who will get their hands on those resources will use those resources for the benefit of the people and not for themselves, their friends and relatives.

    The people who will have control of these resources will not be you or me. They will be the people which you and I will vote to power and if you and I do not use our votes wisely, we will let the corrupt and incompetent people in and will remain impoverished for ever and ever. And it will be our fault.



  • anyname

    U r going in altogether different direction. Please think on two following points.

    a) Did our votes brought Zia , Mush , Ayub , Yahya to power who ruled around 34 years out of last 54 years ?

    b) Do our votes translate into results or its decided in GHQ (Please remember IJI of 88/90 , PIF 93 , MMA / Q-Leauge of 02)



  • Daily bomb blasts and murders in provincial Capitals like Quetta, Karachi and Peshawar clearly indicate the failure of provinces and demand urgent changes in the administration and establishment of these unnatural provinces.