کیا کراچی میں حالیہ فسادات کراچی کو الگ صوبہ بنانے کی سارش ہے؟



  • کیا کراچی میں حالیہ فسادات کراچی کو الگ صوبہ بنانے کی سارش ہے؟

    http://ummat.com.pk/story/2012/03/29/2329/



  • Why not if punjab can be cut into 2 or 3 why not Sind kp bolchistan.double standards.

    I think in Punjab one potohar ,Lahore,saraki,

    Kp should have hazara,fata and kp.sind Karachi,interior Sind and third bit I don't know,

    Same thing with bolochistan at least 3 parts.

    This way we will have less haterd and provincial power will be reduced and racism .

    Easy to mange ppl will have better life more jobs etc



  • Why not if punjab can be cut into 2 or 3 why not Sind kp bolchistan.double standards.

    I think in Punjab one potohar ,Lahore,saraki,

    Kp should have hazara,fata and kp.sind Karachi,interior Sind and third bit I don't know,

    Same thing with bolochistan at least 3 parts.

    This way we will have less haterd and provincial power will be reduced and racism .

    Easy to mange ppl will have better life more jobs etc



  • بھائی جی آپ درست کہہ رہے ہیں کہ اگر پنجاب میں نئے صوبے بن سکتے ہیں تو سندھہ، خیبر پختنخواہ اور بلوچستان میں بھی بن سکتے ہیں۔ اگر نئے صوبے بنائے جائیں تو وہ انتظامی بنیادوں پر ہونے چاہیئے، لسانی بنیادوں پر نہیں۔ اور وہ صوبے دنگا فساد کرکے نہیں افہام و تفہیم سے بننے چاہیئے۔



  • @Admin

    ایڈمن جی سے درخواست ہے کہ اس دھاگے کا ٹائٹل تبدیل کر کے یہ رکھہ دیں۔۔۔۔۔۔کیا کراچی میں حالیہ فسادات کراچی کو الگ صوبہ بنانے کی سارش ہے؟



  • punjab ko is liya cut kiya ja raha ha k pakistan ki tareekh main pahli baar punjab anti-establishment ha. hamari estab. ko julab lagay hoya hain; isi liya apni taraf se aik budho ko tayar kiya ha



  • Smaller provinces will be better in terms of administration.



  • @Admin

    ایڈمن جی ٹائیٹل تبدیل کرنے کا شکریہ



  • Hussain Farooqi

    I am agreed with you

    I already post lot of realistic a& practical (i do not say ideal as nothing perfect as room for improvement always there) suggestion but not get attention like 20 provinces of Pakistan. links are there

    http://www.express.com.pk/epaper/PoPupwindow.aspx?newsID=1100642585&Issue=NP_LHE&Date=20090607

    http://pkpolitics.com/discuss/topic.php?id=4186#post-34622



  • Karachi should be a separate province to administer it efficiently and effectively. We need 20 more provinces throughout Pakistan to provide better services to her citizens.

    Strong local Govt system should be set up throughout Pakistan.





  • @irshad

    That is why I say: set up more provinces then we can find killers as well. Current system of one province in Sind and for a Karachi population of 17 million people has completely failed.

    Sind Govt has completely failed to maintain normal law and order in its capital city and the chief reason is poor administration for a large population city.



  • MQM has history of many crimes back in Pakistan including massive murders of political opponents and physical torture of political workers of other political parties as well as MQM itself who either decided to oppose the policies of MQM´s leadership or openly confronted ALTAF HUSSAIN who is the founder of MQM and is considered to be the main person who calls the shots. Despite the fact that MQM does have a proper advisory council which discusses MQM´s policies but the decision power still rests with ALTAF HUSSAIN. This is why, a firm policy of MQM has been propagated among all the party workers which says "JO QUAID KA GHADDAR HAY , MAUT KA HAQDAR HAY" which means "WHOSOEVER BETRAYS OUR LEADER (ALTAF HUSSAIN) DESERVES TO DIE (i.e. deserves to be killed).



  • @swettruth

    MQM will never go for seperate province but just blaikmailing the governments only.

    reason: if new province created MQM will loose power becz international media will focus on new states and small politics parties among muhajirs,relegious ,defferent ethnics parties will emerge and center of power will no longer will be with MQM.

    next thing is that new province may came in existance but no benifit until the same faces will rule with same mentality..

    eliminate ALtaf other wise karachi will be no go area for all pakistanees if new province created..keep my word as a historical if u belive me..



  • We definitely need a separate province for Urban Sindh.

    Sindh Govt..the waderas..have no interest in the governance of Province. They have zero interest in law n order as long as there are 5000 policemen standing outside their house. They have zero interest in transportation since they and their families travel in tinted glass Prados with police squad or private guards. They have zero interest in economy because they make all their money through kickbacks and corruption. They have no connection with the ordinary citizen and don't give a damn about them

    A separate province will bring in government which will be responsive to the needs of people

    Also, a provincial capital in interior Sindh will be good for the people of interior Sindh. They wont have to travel to Karachi for all their needs



  • @Irshad

    Creation of new province issue is above politics and it will provide better administration and services to local population. During my last visit to Karachi couple of years ago, I found massive support for MQM and you are talking about eliminating MQM and its leadership.

    Didin't we do the same in East Pakistan? Instead of handing over power to Mujeeb/Awami League after their clear election win, we insulted their manadate, arrested its leadership and responded public protest with tanks and bullets. Your strong views certainly prove you have not learnt lessons from past national mistakes. What would you feel if PPP is denied power after its clear win either in Sind or whole Pakistan?

    My point is simple; do not deny MQM's mandate (or any other party in pakistan) otherwise you will have same negative results (separatist voices) as we are currently having in Balochistan.

    Come up with clear reasons why you do not want a separate province in Karachi. I want 20 more provinces throughout Pakistan to improve delivery of services to general public.

    Have 4 provinces for the last 40 years solved your problems? I would say our day-to-day problems are multiplying fast in the presence of 4 provinces.

    In order to improve law and order situation, it is time to create a new province in Karachi.



  • عجیب منطق اور منافقت ہے

    پنجاب اور خیبر پختون خواہ کو تقسیم کرنے کی باتیں ہوں تو وہ عوامی مطالبہ اور عوام کا جائز حق لیکن سندھ کو تقسیم کرنے یا کراچی کو صوبہ بنانے کی بات ہو تو وہ سازش

    ہمیں پہلے یہ فیصلہ کر لینا چاہیے کہ پرانے صوبوں کی تقسیم اور نئے صوبوں کا قیام عوامی و ملکی مفاد ہے یا عوام اور ملک کے خلاف سازش؟



  • @bawa

    Creation of more provinces throughout the country is in favour of general public not against and it has its multiple benefits. It is not a conspiracy as mentioned by Irshad above.



  • @ Sweettruth

    بالکل درست کہا ہے آپ نے

    سندھ کی کل ساڑھے پانچ کروڑ آبادی میں سے آدھی آبادی کراچی میں رہتی ہے

    پھر سندھ کی نئے صوبوں میں تقسیم پر چیخ و پکار کیسی؟



  • Basically the Sindhi elite living in Karachi is against the new province.

    Provincial Capital in Interior Sindh would bring relief to the Sindhis actually living in interior Sindh