کیا اب مہاجر صوبے اور دیگر صوبوں کا قیام نا گزیر ہے؟؟؟؟



  • صدر زرداری کے سرائیکی صوبے کے اعلان کے بعد کیا اب توقع کر سکتے ہیں کہ سندھ میں مہاجر صوبے کے علاوہ خیبر پختون خواہ میں ہزارہ صوبہ اور بلوچستان میں پختون خواہ صوبے کا قیام بھی نا گزر ہوگیا ہے اور اس طرح زرداری لعنتی بھٹو کی طرح اپنے سیاسی مفادات کے لیے ملک کے سب حصوں میں ایک دوسرے کے خلاف نفرت کی آگ پھیلا کر خدا نخواستہ ملک کے مزید ٹکڑے کرنے جا رہا ہے؟

    اور یوں ملک کی مزید تقسیم کرکے وہ اپنے روحانی باپ اور سسر مردود بھٹو کی روح کو تسکین پہچانا چاہتا ہے؟

    .

    .



  • PPP in 1970, udher tum idher hum

    PPP in 1973 Rich vs Poor

    PPP in 1990 Punjabi vs sindhi

    PPP in 2012 Punjabi vs Seraika

    No Doubt PPP is getting more divisive by day and going down too.



  • is begharat ko wese to vote milne nahi isi tara ke harbo he kam chalan chahta ha !!!



  • PPP cannot manage provinces under its allies control. Only province peaceful which is not under PPP control. They are getting jealous of it and wanna destroy that peace too.

    Otherwise nothing gonna come out of it.



  • There is no way to make Saraiki province before next elections .

    And there is no mandate with anyone for new provinces .

    I repeat administrated divisions of five each of every province can solve many problems at this stage but who cares .



  • What's wrong with more provinces. I support more provinces. be it Hazara, Potohar, Malakand, Seraiki, Karachi.

    We need more provinces.



  • باوا جی

    اس پر بھی تو روشنی ڈالیں کہ کیا یہ ممکن ہے

    کیا پی پی پی اپنے طور پر صوبہ بنا سکتی ہے



  • انصاف تک صاحب

    کہیں آپ دشمن کے دشمن سے دوستی والا حساب تو نہیں کر رہے

    کیا سرائیکی صوبے کیلیے خان صاحب زرداری کی آواز میں آواز ملائیں گے



  • @ Easy go

    PTI supports more provinces. Imran Khan has been on record for a long time about this and confirmed that again in Abbotabad Jalsa with Examples of turkey and Japan two countries that have less population than Pakistan and have far more provinces.

    I think everyone should support more provinces and local government system.



  • i start writing on that 3 years back on this forum.

    100% bias less purely on administrative base need 20 provinces in pkistan. here is the link

    http://pkpolitics.com/discuss/topic/provinces-of-pakistan-need-to-reorganized-1

    but so called danishwar of this forum don't have vision that time and still i think so.........

    sorry in advance but one of myself quote

    If you not accept the facts, facts compel you to accept themselves.

    one day it will be happen but so called Muhiban-e- watan never accept it.





  • @ANWER KAMAL

    Have you read my proposal, which province on the bases of language, ethnicity or religion. All bases on administrative, mean population and area.



  • I tried a lot on the issue although I am not well educated and know nothing about computer except typing or copying and but I have found some natural five divisions of each province and if we promote those as administrative divisions or sub-provinces it can solve many of our problems at this stage .



  • yeah i m agree with it, i proposed that this is ideal situation if we make each division as province.

    in my proposal i tried to be province with almost equal population and areas so no single province has the commanding position such as now. Even all four provinces (Sindh, Bal, KPK and GB) seats are less than single Punjab province.



  • People love their traditions and history . No need to ask them for strange things .

    I am my self surprised that how we are neglecting the smaller issues and later those become the bigger one.

    We have given very less opportunities to our 80 % areas to develop and that is the major cause of our failure in every field.

    I am looking concerns of Karachi people and I am very sad for people of Dera Ismaell Khan who have no voice any where.

    I am very happy to see that people of every region love Pakistan and if you can visit different sites representing local views and facebook pages, You will see their love to Pakistan although there is some unrest in Balochistan but still able to be managed with love and respect.

    In the light of 18th amendment provinces have got more powers and now able to do more.

    If you look at history and our present regions all the four provinces have a natural division of five each.

    Sindh

    Karachi, Larkana, Hyderabd, Khairpur and Sukkur

    Punjab

    Bahwalpur, Multan. Pothohar,Lahore and Thull (Sargodh ,Mianwali etc)

    KP

    Peshawar ,Malakand,Hazarah, Dera and FATA

    Baluchistan

    Four states and Quetta Zhob , excluding enclave of Gawadar.

    (Gawadar and Rajanpur should be given status of Federal Districts)

    Gawadar should be made a 100% free port

    We can give them all a present status of Sub provinces or administrative division with a deputy governor and minimum 50 % provincial rights to their councils may be consisting the elected MNAs , MPAs and senators.

    They should be given a ten years time to act as sub province and later they could ask more or less.



  • Must think about this



  • @insaftak

    Has IK ever managed even a Union Council, let alone a country. How does he propose to manage cost of five or six new provincial parliaments, with their armies of MPAs, ministers, advisors, parliamentary secretaries, and so on.

    Why doesn't he start by proposing Karachi suba first?



  • please give the link of this map, i could not find



  • انتظامی بنیادوں پر صوبوں کی تقسیم پر کسی کو بھی اعتراض نہیں ہے اور اس سے عوام کی بہت ساری مشکلات حل ہونگی لیکن سیاسی مفادات حاصل کرنے کی خاطر صوبوں کی تقسیم نفرتوں کو جنم دے گی

    زرداری اور اسکے حواریوں کی منافقت کی انتہا ہے کہ وہ پنجاب کی تقسیم کا ورد تو دن رات کرتے ہیں لیکن جب سندھ کی تقسیم کی بات ہو توانکے کانوں سے دھواں نکلنے لگتا ہے

    حقیقت یہ ہے کہ انکی اتنی اوقات ہی نہیں ہے کہ وہ کسی صوبے کی آئینی طریقے سے ترمیم کرکے تقسیم کروا سکیں لیکن صرف سیاسی مفاد حاصل کرنے کی خاطر سرائیکی صوبے کا شور مچاتے رہیں گے اور سرائیکیوں بولنے والوں کو بے وقوف بناتے رہیں گے

    وہ یہ بھی جانتے ہیں کہ ایک بار پنجاب کی تقسیم کا عمل شروع ہوا تو سندھ میں مہاجر صوبے کو کوئی نہیں روک سکے گا



  • What abt this proposal

    . In my opinion the structure of Pakistan state is to unstable due to 60% of population in one province and 45% of area in one province.

    If we can make each division a province is the best if not than at least 5 or 6 for Punjab 4 for Sindh, 4 for NWFP 4 Balochistan and 1 Northern area and 2 for FATA. Detail is given below

    Punjab Provinces

    Punjab east (Majhi) - Lahore division + Sailkot + Narowal districts

    Punjab north ( Pothohar) – Pindi division

    Punjab central – Faisalabad and Gujranwala division except districts includes in Punjab east

    Punjab west ( Sandal or Doaba (due to Sindh and Chinab river) - Sargoda + Deraghazi khan division

    Punjab south ( Sariki or Thal ) – Multan and Bahwalpur division

    Sindh Provinces

    Sindh South ( Kolachi) – Karachi division + Thata + Badin District

    Sindh centeral – Haider Abad + Nawab shah Divisions

    Sindh West – Larkana division and all area on west of river Sindh from Sakhar

    Sindh North – Sakhar division

    Pakhtoonkhawa Provices

    Pakhtoonkhawa west – Peshawar division

    Swat – All swat areas

    Pakhtoonkhawa south – Dera ismail khan + Banu division

    Hazara – Abbot abad and hazara jat

    Balochistan Provinces

    Balochistan north – Quetta and sibi division

    Kalat – mostly old kalat areas

    Balochistan east – lasbell + winder + khuzdar

    Balochistan west – Gawadar +Pasni + turbat and surroundings

    Federal areas

    Northern Areas

    Fata North

    Fata South

    In the above mention situation any province has maximum population of 15% of total (such as Karachi , Lahore or Faisalabad provinces) which restrict the bargaining position or monopoly of Punjab for central government. Area also not has too big in the same way so the funds should be distributed on the basis of 50% population and 50% area.